Could plasma light extend Moore’s law?
July 2, 2012

The lab equipment includes a small system that measures plasma for electronics applications, attached to a larger tank containing plasma for energy research (credit: University of Washington)
A University of Washington lab says it can produce light with enough power to be used in manufacturing microchips.
The lab has been working for more than a decade on fusion energy, harnessing the energy-generating mechanism of the sun.
But in one of the twists of scientific discovery, on the way the researchers found a potential solution to a looming problem in the electronics industry.
“To get smaller feature sizes on silicon, the industry has to go to shorter wavelength light,” said Uri Shumlak, a UW professor of aeronautics and astronautics. The UW beam lasts up to 1,000 times longer than competing technologies and provides more control over the million-degree plasma that produces the light.
For more than four decades the technology industry has kept up with Moore’s Law, a prediction that the number of transistors on a computer chip will double every two years. This trend has allowed ever-smaller, faster, lighter and less energy-intensive electronics. But it’s hit a roadblock: the current 193-nanometer ultraviolet light cannot be used for circuits any smaller.
The industry has determined that the future standard for making microchips will be 13.5-nanometer light, a wavelength less than 1/14 the current size that should carry the industry for years to come. Such extreme ultraviolet light can be created only from plasmas, which are high-temperature, electrically charged gases in which electrons are stripped from their nuclei.
The electronics industry is trying to produce this extreme ultraviolet light in various ways. One takes a droplet of tin and shoots it with a laser to make plasma that releases a brief spark of light. But so far this spark is too brief. Chip manufacturers use a $100 million machine to bounce light off a series of mirrors and eventually project the light onto a silicon wafer; each step absorbs some of the light’s energy.
“Over the past decade, the primary issue with these extreme ultraviolet light sources is they just can’t produce enough power,” Shumlak said. “It’s a stumbling block for the whole semiconductor industry.”
Fusion scientists, it turns out, are plasma experts. The hydrogen plasma in the sun is so hot that hydrogen nuclei fuse together and release energy. Scientists around the world, including at the UW, are working to replicate this on Earth. A fusion reactor would use hydrogen as its fuel and emit helium as a waste product, a technically challenging but clean source of energy.
The UW group’s specialty is a lower-cost version of a fusion reactor that uses currents flowing through the material, rather than giant magnets, to contain the million-degree plasma. Their method also produces plasma that is stable and long-lived.
“It’s a completely different way to make the plasma that gives you much more control,” said Brian Nelson, a UW research associate professor of electrical engineering.
Light produced through techniques now being considered by the chip industry generate a spark that lasts just 20 to 50 nanoseconds. Zplasma’s light beam lasts 20 to 50 millionths of a second, about 1,000 times longer.
“That translates directly into more light output, more power depositing on the wafer, such that you can move it through in some reasonable amount of time,” Shumlak said.
To bring their solution to market two UW engineers have launched a startup, Zplasma. An initial grant from the UW’s Center for Commercialization allowed the team to verify that it could produce 13.5-nanometer light. A gift last fall from the Washington Research Foundation helped the team shrink the equipment from the size of a broomstick to a new version the size of a pin, which can produce a sharp beam.
The group will continue its fusion research project funded by the U.S. Department of Energy. Raymond Golingo, a UW research scientist in aeronautics and astronautics, is co-author of the patent for the technology issued in 2008.
Comments (9)
by rob falgiano
@Gordon, that same thought had occurred to me – that the coming efficiencies of robots will eventually make humans much more useless on the whole. Which way will it go – will we live in a luxurious paradise of free time b/c replicated food will solve world hunger, or will we begin dying off like the less evolved ancestors of cavemen?
by Brian Roberts
I would think (at least from the predictions made) is that quantum computing when developed will have a “quantum law” that dwarfs Moore’s law. Agree 100% Gordon on the carbon nanotubes and graphene.
by Editor
Yes, the ITRS forecast for Moore’s law only extends to a 6 nm gate length, in 2026. Below that, quantum effects dominate.
by Gorden Russell
Yes Brian, a lot of researchers have a lot of irons in a lot of fires, and they will keep pullng our nuts out of the fire. Another big thing to keep Moore’s Law going are carbon nanotubes and graphene. You can make transistors with either of them. We will have Moore’s Law going strong all the way up to the Singularity.
by Miller A.
Overall this is a pretty accurate article, so it’s surprising to see this statement:
“But it’s hit a roadblock: the 193-nanometer ultraviolet light now being used cannot etch circuits any smaller.” This line reads as though the light is used to directly etch circuits, whereas the light is used in the process of patterning the cicuits, not in etching.
by Editor
Good catch. Fixed.
by Gorden Russell
“A gift last fall from the Washington Research Foundation helped the team shrink the equipment from the size of a broomstick to a new version the size of a pin, which can produce a sharp beam.”
Remember Senator Proxmire? He was the scoffer who always criticised scientific research paid for by the Federal Government. Without money from the Department of Energy, we wouldn’t have this new breakthkrough. This will give us the von Neumann machines that will mine asteroids at Lagrange Point Five.
Of course, this will put us all out of work when robots build robots. They will be so cheap and plentiful that they will do every job.
These robots will just have to pay the unemployment taxes of the people they replace, or society will collapse.
by Brian Roberts
I’ve heard Moore’s law will last the decade or maybe 2. By then quantum computing would likely keep it going. If Moore’s law stopped I don’t really think things would come to a halt. Isn’t 3-d chip architecture supposed to increase the law as well?
by DeBee Corley
Wow, a 20 millionth of a second light beam can be used to produce chips.
Probably a lot of work to do.