Faster-than-light neutrinos dealt another blow
January 5, 2012 | Source: New Scientist
The OPERA detector (credit: INFN)
A team including Shmuel Nussinov of Tel Aviv University in Israel says the OPERA report that neutrinos faster than light also violates the principle of the conservation of energy.
The energy available to faster-than-light neutrinos from the CERN source (pions) is too small by a factor of 10 to explain the speeds reported, they said.
Ref.: Ramanath Cowsik1, Shmuel Nussinov, and Utpal Sarkar, Superluminal Neutrinos at OPERA Confront Pion Decay Kinematics, Physical Review Letters, 2011 [DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.251801]
Comments (50)
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
As often mentioned, please give me a letter to the address. I’ll send you my articles unpublished anywhere. MEU is very important and real cosmology which no body has thought of.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Thank Dr. Whittaker for the first response to my theory which you have perhaps never heard of. The Many-Worlds Theory (MEU) is not so difficult, but unknown to anyone. It takes long words to post. In fact, I have posted in this website, however, it was instataneously blocked. I’m very poor at IT. As you say, I’ll try to post my theory on arXir.org or pdftribute. net. which I can’t understand what means. Tomorrow I’ll send! Good night.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Why do you block my Many-Worlds Theory so often? It’s very important information of current cosmology. If you use it, OK. As I have posted many times, the inflation scenario and the accelerated expansion are completely false. As its proof, they cannot explain even the WMAP data in CMB.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I have found that the important Many-Worlds theory posted yesterday was lost this morning. Why? I’s very long one.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Sorry. Again many mistypes, but you can easily find where I have mistaken.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
My cosmology includes many intuitively obtained equations which are proven correct because the WMAP data coincide with their results;i.e. MEU (multi-Euclidean universe). My articles have never been accepted by any journal partly because they are too long and quite different from hitherto established theories. Therefore, who wishes to know MEU had better give me a letter to the address: Toshiaki Asano M.D. Kawada Hospital, 2-15-21, Tomimachi, Kitaku, Okayama City, 700-0031, Japan, I’ll surely send him my articles by airmail with no charge. I’m glad if he uses them freely without worrying about copy rights because I only hope MEU may be widely known in the world.
by Whittaker
Sounds like fringe science but I still want to know more. Please post your theory on arXiv.org or pdftribute.net.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I think that the Planck satellite will prove our universe is multi-Euclidean where Mach’s principle that 100% of the inertial masses in the universe results from mutual gravitational interplay and the dark matter is axions which makes up just 1/4 and the dark energy is massive virtual gravitons which maskea up just 2/3. The present mass of a virtual graviton is 1.1018778^-66 g; i.e.Qh-bar/c^2 t,t the cosmic time, Q=1.5249902121,the new universal constant
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Saint Shinran (1173-1262) said ” Even the good go to heaven, much more the bad.”
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
My some comments will give you enough hint to rediscover MEU. Please submit your article to prove MEU which can be accepted by any journal. And then, our world will become more peaceful. MORE HUMAN HAPPINESS!
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
For only virtual gravitons, it’s sure that the causality is broken because they are absobed and emitted for the past having the negative momentum –h bar Q/ct which can explain the universal gravity as the results of bexchanges of virtual gravitons between two bodies. In the multi-Euclidean universe only which can explain the WMAP data (2001-2008) and perhaps the the multi-Euclidean universe only which can explain the WMAP data (2001-2008) and perhaps the Planck data (2009-2012), every universe has the same physical laws as ours. Dr. Sankar has concepts which are too abstract,unreal and unphysical. Physics must be treated more physically For instance, even too abstract,unreal and unphysical. Physics must be treated more physically For instance, even general relativity is too geometrical and has no meanim\ngful cosmological solutions anymore. Nowadays general relativity can never produce such the solution as multi-Euclidean universe where the thermal fluctuations of first peak is 5718microK^2 and the most suppressed thermal fluctuayions is 173microK^2 in CMB.
by Er.K.Sankar
I am related with Indian Institute of Technology, Indian Space Research Organisation and National Aeronautics and Space Administration and now member of Search for Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence for topics of fourth law of motion, slower or faster than light travel, aliens ufos theoretical and practical study realisation, and unconventional method of rocket launching, fourth and fifth state of matter, and fourth dimension, life before birth and life after death and time machine concepts. Kindly reply to my mail for further improvements of inter-planetary, interstellar, and intergalaxy travels.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Ferm’s constant g for beta-decay and mean life t(m) : We have got g^2=alpha^-8 G h-bar c^4 m(e)^3 (h-bar)^7/ 2 pi^3 e^6 m(e)^5 c^4 = 2.007 10^-98 erg^2 cm^6. We can introduce t(m) of a neutron as x=2 pi^3/Q x, t(m)=alpha^8 2 pi^3 cosmic time x/Q, and t(m)=909.621 sec.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
At least, we can say that the more information you have, the less creativity you may have.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
We conclude the retardation of proper time in gravitational fields and in a Minkowski space occurs by the presence of virtual gravitons which break down the causality because they are absorbed and emitted for the past. The particle horizon of MEU is 4.147095 10^10 light years away from us because MEU is 1.382365 10^10 years of age.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
We have proven that Riemann’s zeta function for 2n+1 and Euler’s constant are transcendental.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
The apparent luminosity of SN is proportional to (1+z)^4 [{(1+z)^0.5 +1+z}/z]^2.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I highly evaluate Henri Bergson (1859-1941)’s works “Matter and Memory” (1896) and “Duration and Simultaneity” (1922). In my own view, consciousness results not only from the brain, but fundamentally from the MEU and Simultaneity can be intuitively understood by the cosmic time the absolute time. For example, at this moment, the cosmic time at the particle horizon (4.142365 10^10 light years away from us) is equal to that of us.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Karl Jaspers ” We cannot be conscious of what does not exist as not exist.” If you think that God exists, you can easily understand MEU only which is the exact cosmological solution and can explain evrything in our universe where the inseparability between other universes(aleph one) and Mach’s principle play an important role. MEU shows that WE HAVE NO FREE WILL which must change human life.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Although I know the high ability of Brian Greene et al. and Hitoshi Murayama of IPMU, I can’t evaluate their results of studies. For example, they cannot explain the dark energy and neutrinos faster than light.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
If you fully understand that WE HAVE NO FREE WILL, our world will surely become far more peaceful. So I’m posting comment that our universe is multi-Euclidean.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I couldn’t lerve comments until now. Many thanks for your kindness. Dark energy is quite different from cosmological constant or vacuum energy. As already mentioned frequently, it’s virtual gravitons. Why don’t you think of the continously infinite Euclidean universe? It’s easy if you suppose our universe was created by God. The entropy S is 9pi c^5 k(B) t^2/4G h-bar. That’s all. We here quantize gravity. A body absorbs a virtual graviton of the momentum h-bar Q/ct for the past and emits it in the centripetal direction of mass at the center for the past. By means of this new supposition we can understand the universal gravity as the results of exchanges of virtual gravitons between two bobies. We assume that the virtual gravitonsw do not obey the new transformations but they obey the Galilean trasformation because they have always the cosmic time as their proper time. The dark matter and dark energy are derived from virtual gravitons whose interactions are very weak. Dark matter is axion (4.95 10^-5 eV/c^2) and dark energy is virtual graviton (4.1018778 10^-66g). They are nomore dark. As for neutrino masses, electron neutrino pi^(3-Q) alpha^-1 m(axion)=6.541058 10^-35g muon neutrino pi^1.5 alpha^-1 m(axion)=6.7350468 10^-35g and tau neutrino pi^2 alpha^-1 m(axion)=1.1937559 10^-34g. We show some relations: G h-bar c^4 m(e)^3 t=Q e^6 which givesexact ages of MEU. Q=8 alpha/3 pi [ pi m(e)/32 alpha^2 m(proton) -- 1 ]=1.5249902121 the new universal constant. At the end, we insist that the retardation of proper time in physics occurs by the presence of virtual gravitons which break down the causality because they are absorbed and emitted for the past.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I have a Japanese paper entitled “The universe and physics” (Oct. 1987) unpublished anywhere and written by using Ernst Mach(1838-1916)’s idea. This paper proves that our universe is continuously infinite multi-Euclidean and that the difficulties in QED can be solved. Mach’s principle is the most important issue of physics although it is erroneously believed nowadays useless. The universe without it can never physically exist. Like the origin of inertial mass, 100% of the observed electric and magnetic charges result from the gravitational interplay. If one neglects Mach’s principle, one cannot get the exact structure of the universe; i.e. MEU.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I don’t believe the inflation scenario and the accelerated expansion of the universe where axions the “dark matter” make up just 1/4 and virtual gravitons the “dark energy” make up just 2/3.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
As mentioned, I owe much to J.S.Bell. His comments in BBC interview brought about MEU i.e. the exact time of an observastion at the quantum level and the second law of thermodynamics at the level. I’m glad to requite him with the exact time of an observation.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Repeated neutrinos experiments will always show different result or speed of neutrinos because any observer is moving every moment relative to ether or virtual gravitons. This is simple fact.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
This night I was deeply moved as i had never experienced before by TV broadcasted fact that 3 German sightseeing travellers (Spiegelberg’s family) were rescued from TSUNAMI on March 11th 2011 by Japanese people who might not think of what they did because they behaved as a matter of course. Not only Japanese and Germans, all in the world must be moved by this fact. Johanna, duplicated congratulations! Congratulations Japanese people!
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I’m sorry posting duplicated comments that neutrinos can travel at some time faster than light and can’t at other time. It seems to me that few people look up my comment on neutrinos, while many people refer to famous physicists iin vain.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
The most important fact is that nobody has ever observed the system S at rest from a sysem S’ which is moving relative to the substratum or ether with a speed nearly equal to that of light. This is the reason why special relativity is wrong for only objects (e.g.neutrinos) and virtual gravitons. Neutrinos can move superluminously at some cosmic time, but cannot at other time depending on the observer’s speed relative to ether.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Although Feynman(1918-1988) believed in the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, I would think he was right at that time when unphysical multiverse or parallel universes was argued. As already mentioned, I insist that our universe is multi-Euclidean where inseparability between other universes whose potency is aleph one, and Mach’s principle play a crucial role. Sorry I’m posting duplicated comments because my papers have never been accepted by any journal. I thank Prof. Mikio Namiki who had the kindness to read my Japanese paper entitled ” The universe and physics ” and to send me a brief comment with encouragement to publish it, but at that time I had not yet quantized gravity (1987). The excessive suppression of power spectrum in CMB as an evidence of the multi-Euclidean universe (2008,unpublished) was typed by Mr. Kazuhiro Akagi and it has 27 sheets of paper including many intuitively obtained equations, which will be surely rejected.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Anyone can intuitively understand that the spatially limited universe without a boundary can never physically exist. Physicists who believed in general relativity could’n understand this! In this case, intuitive thinking is better than complicated culculations. Very instructive.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I thank J.S.Bell(1928-1990) for comments(BBC interview) on aether which redeems physics from Einstein’s theory and philosophy that non-observable thing does not exist. His theory has brought physics the current situation. This is also the reason why physicist can never think of aether.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I thank J.S.Bell(1928-1990) for comments(BBC interview) on aether which redeems physics from Einstein’s theory and philosophy that non-observable thing does not exist. His theory has brought physics the current situation. This is also the reason why physicist can never think of aether the virtual gravitons.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I thank J.S.Bell(1928-1990) for comments(BBC interview) on aether which redeems physics from Einstein’s theory and philosophy that non-observable thing does not exist. His theory has brought physics the current situation. This is also the reason why physicist can never think of virtual gravitons which constitute everything.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
As reported by NHK, I also think INTUITION on the basis of informations (not too many) makes the best work in any field. This is not duplicasted cmment.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
As reported by NHK, I also think INTUITION on the basis of informations (not too many) makes the best work in any field.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Yesterday, again new judge of putting a person to death in Japan was reported. Why do even judges such great mistake? The reason why they judge death is the their ignorance of MEU which proves that we have no free will; i.e. any criminal or sinner could never behave otherwise. Therefore, MEU must be globally understood.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
It’s sure that we are living in revolutinary times in every field.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
These pages cannot print. Why?
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Last night NHK reported about neutrinos faster than light. However it is obvious that neutrinos can travel faster than light, which I have proven in ” The excessive suppression of power spectrum in CMB at the large angular size as an evidence of multi-Euclidean universe (MEU) ” (2008 unpublished)
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
There are many comments in other websites which I can’t find anymore. Please find them by yourself. You will surely understand that we have brought about completely new creation in physics although I am merely a psychiatrist working for Kawada Hospital in Okayama City. I have not easily believed in any authority or hitherto established theory. This is most important way to create something. I have already submitted a paper entitled ” Ultimate structure of our universe is multi-Euclidean “(2002) to NATURE which was of course rejected. Creative matter seems to take this way as shown by history. Please think this over and over again who wish to be creative.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I’m glad to have posted comments on MEU, God, unconsciousness, our unity and the truth. We don’t die, but enter new life, which is being clinically proven. MANY THANKS!
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
We Japanese only wish NEVER WARS AGAIN in our planet which is so tiny one. Let’s always think on the cosmological scale and be united on this. From the universe, the earth is blue and beatiful enough. So NEVER WARS!
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Japanese only want NEVER WARS AGAIN in OUR PLANET! why wars in so tiny planet! Let’s always think on the cosmological scale and be united for human happiness. THIS IS FAR BETTER THAN WARS. SIMPLE IS BEST.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Why can’t I print my comments? I’m very poor at IT. Please tell me.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Why cannot I leave comments as ERRATA?
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I hope every struggle due to difference of religion may be abolished because any religion is united in only one God=unconsciousness where existence is united including dead, alive man, animal, plant and inanimates. Becaese MEU proves WE HAVE NO FREE WILL, we cannot put a person to death. Any criminal or sinner could not behave otherwise. All is dermined by MEU. The revenge, punishment, terrorism and war are derived from ignorance of MEU. It’s great misunderstand that human being goes to war for religious differences. We Japanese have PEACE constitution which renounces war.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
We have found electron mass/electron neutrino mass=Q^4 alphs^-3 where a new universal constant Q=8 alpha/3 pi [ pi electron mass/32 alpha^2 proton mass -- 1 ]^-1=1.5249902121. The absolute mass of neutrinos is as follows: electron neutrino mass=6.5451058 10^-35g =pi^(3-Q) alpha^-1 m(axion), muon neutrino mass =6.7350468 10^-35g =pi^1.5 alpha^-1 m(axion), tau neutrino mass =1.1937559 10^34g =pi^2 alpha^-1.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
Those who wish to know MEU the new paradigm in physics had better send a letter to the address: Toshiaki Asano M.D. Kawada Hospital 2-15-21 Tomimachi, Kitaku, Okayama City, 700-0031, JAPAN.
by Toshiaki Asano M.D.
I explain the reason why neutrinos could move faster than light using my cosmology. At first, I put in four space-time a system S(x,t) at rest relative to the hypothetically assumed substratum comoving with the expanding matter in the universe, and put a system S’(x’,t’) uniformly moving relative to S with a speed v. Except for photons and virtual gravitons, the following equations hold where g denotes the Lorentz factor: x’= (x-vt)/g t’=t/g (1), x= (x’+vt’)g t=gt’ (2). From eqs. (1) and (2), we have v+v’ as the addition theorem for velocities for objects, which means there is a faster than light velocity in the world. From CERN to OPRA (730km), neutrinos took up 60ns faster than the speed of light. This means the following results by (1) and (2): 730km g/t = c+6 10^-8 c, ct = 730km, and g=1+6 10^-8 must hold yielding v=103.85km/s; i.e. the observers were moving at the time at this speed relative to the substratum which is identical to the aether (virtual gravitons which constitute everything in the universe). The mass of a virtual graviton is 4.1018778 10^-66g being proportional to (the cosmic time t)^-2. Our universe is multi-Euclidean (for short, MEU) where the cosmic time is the absolute time and the substratum is the absolute space. There isn’t the relativity of siimultaneity but the relativistic Doppler equation holds. Refer to Toshiaki Asano M.D. and my unpublished papers for example “The excessive suppression of power spectrum in CMB at large angular size as a evidence of MEU”(2008). MEU evolved from infinite volume,density and energy and from zero scalar curvature and entropy. Only MEU can prove why quantum laws, no free will, consciousness and God the Creator exist. This fact will change human life. Moreover unconsciousness = God which is invisible and only one and where every existence is united there whether or not one believes this bringing about new paradigm. This will make the world more peaceful because of religious unity. Struggles for religion will decrease.