Solving the ‘cocktail party problem’: how we can focus on one speaker in noisy crowds
March 11, 2013
This is a cartoon illustrating the idea that at a cocktail party the brain activity synchronizes to that of an attended speaker, effectively putting them ‘on the same wavelength’ (credit: Zion-Golumbic et al./Neuron)
Researchers have demonstrated how the brain hones in on one speaker to solve the “cocktail party problem.”
Researchers discovered that the brain can selectively track the sound patterns from the speaker of interest and at the same time exclude competing sounds from other speakers.
The findings could have important implications for helping individuals with a range of deficits such as those associated with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, autism, and aging.
“In hearing, there is no way to ‘close your ear,’ so all the sounds in the environment are represented in the brain, at least at the sensory level,” explains senior author Dr. Charles Schroeder, of Columbia University’s Department of Psychiatry.
“While confirming this, we also provide the first clear evidence that there may be brain locations in which there is exclusive representation of an attended speech segment, with ignored conversations apparently filtered out.” In this way, when concentrating hard on such an “attended” speaker, one is barely, if at all, aware of ignored speakers.
Using direct recording of brain activity in surgical epilepsy patients, who were listening to natural spoken sentences, Dr. Schroeder and Dr. Elana Zion Golumbic, also of Columbia University, and their colleagues from New York University, University of Maryland, and Hillside-Long Island Jewish found two types of effects.
In and near auditory cortex, brain signals reflect both attended and ignored speech, but attended speech generates higher signal amplitudes. However, in regions of the brain involved in “higher-order processing,” such as language and attention control, representation of attended speech was clear, while that of ignored speech was not detectable. Remarkably, the selective, higher-order representation is progressively refined as a sentence unfolds.
“This will stimulate future research to continue the study of this and related issues under rich, natural conditions.
“Just as importantly, the ability to directly analyze widespread brain activity patterns in surgical epilepsy patients provides an unprecedented opportunity to firmly connect the work on the Brain Activity Map at the model systems level in mice, songbirds, and nonhuman primates to the study of capacities like language and music, that may be uniquely human.”
Comments (10)
by asiwel
I don’t quite understand? They just “discovered” this human ability? Where in the world have they been? Obviously, the ability to do this is a function of the brain and probably the auditory centers. What I had hoped to read was that they had actually figured out “how” the brain achieves this effect in such a way that the process could be modeled, duplicated, and improved upon in hardware and software.
by matthew
its poorly written and you can only know whats new in terms of the science by reading the original article.
by asiwel
@matthew – You are exactly right. I usually do read such an otherwise interesting sounding article and certainly should have done so first this time. This is excellent research that elucidates a great deal about how the brain actually achieves this important effect … which most clearly involves “intention” to focus on the salient aspects of the stimuli, from the “bottom-up” and the “top-down” and improving the filtering over message attention time. Sort of demonstrates the hierarchical nature of the networks involved, a la Ray Kurzweil’s recent book.
by Editor
We have acquired the research paper and will be posting a more technical story soon.
by asiwel
Oh, good. Thank you. This is a most interesting study, I thought, and very relevant to the general KAI thread of interest.
And, besides, this research might be especially relevant to understanding exactly how (and what) the brain appreciates about music.
by matthew
Don’t worry LME the scientists will be coding up this ability to enhance the next next version of the PlayStation in 10 years.
by LME
“hones in on”???
by kaune
@LME — you have a problem with “hones in on”? Guess you don’t like “homing the blade of my knife” either.
by Foye Lowe
ET, phome hone . . .
by mARK
sure, you hone in on the’re talk weather or not they like it or not. thats english as she is spoke.