We are now one year away from global riots, complex systems theorists say
September 11, 2012
What’s the number one reason we riot? Hunger — food becoming too scarce or too expensive. So argues a group of complex systems theorists in Cambridge, and it makes sense, Motherboard reports.
In a 2011 paper, researchers at the Complex Systems Institute (CSI) unveiled a model that accurately explained why the waves of unrest that swept the world in 2008 and 2011 crashed when they did. The number one determinant was soaring food prices. Their model identified a precise threshold for global food prices that, if breached, would lead to worldwide unrest.
Technology Review explains how CSI’s model works: “The evidence comes from two sources. The first is data gathered by the United Nations that plots the price of food against time, the so-called food price index of the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the UN. The second is the date of riots around the world, whatever their cause.” Plot the data, and it looks like this the above graph.
Black dots are the food prices, red lines are the riots. In other words, whenever the UN’s food price index, which measures the monthly change in the price of a basket of food commodities, climbs above 210, the conditions ripen for social unrest around the world. For billions of people around the world, food comprises up to 80% of routine expenses. When prices jump, people can’t afford anything else; or even food itself. And if you can’t eat — or worse, your family can’t eat — you fight.
Today, the food price index is hovering around 213, where it has stayed for months — just beyond the tip of the identified threshold. Low corn yield in the U.S., the world’s most important producer, has helped keep prices high.
“Recent droughts in the mid-western United States threaten to cause global catastrophe,” Yaneer Bar-Yam, one of the authors of the report, recently told Al Jazeera. “When people are unable to feed themselves and their families, widespread social disruption occurs. We are on the verge of another crisis, the third in five years, and likely to be the worst yet, capable of causing new food riots and turmoil on a par with the Arab Spring.”
Even before the extreme weather scrambled food prices this year, CSI’s 2011 report predicted that the next great breach would occur in August 2013, and that the risk of more worldwide rioting would follow.
But the reality is that such predictions are now all but impossible to make. In a world well-warmed by climate change, unpredictable, extreme weather events like the drought that has consumed 60% of the United States and the record heat that has killed its cattle are now the norm. Just two years ago, heat waves in Russia crippled its grain yield and dealt a devastating blow to global food markets — the true, unheralded father of the Arab Spring was global warming, some say.
And it’s only going to get worse and worse and worse. Because of climate change-exacerbated disasters like these, “the average price of staple foods such as maize could more than double in the next 20 years compared with 2010 trend prices,” a new report from Oxfam reveals. That report details how the poor will be even more vulnerable to climate change-induced food price shocks than previously thought. After all, we’ve “loaded the climate dice,” as NASA’s James Hansen likes to say, and the chances of such disasters rolling out are greater than ever.

Comments (58)
by Steve
Soylent Green will solve this problem.
by Jessie Henshaw
I DO, btw, agree with the title statement, that “We are now one year away from global riots, complex systems theorists say”
It’s equally important to realize that. we are now also 33 years from the first valid complex system theory prediction of just such phenomena as the natural limit to economic growth, if driven to its physical limits.
That valid prediction gave me a huge boost in charting a productive path of research into the related misunderstandings, letting us take such a suicidal path, and for finding the real solutions.
http://www.synapse9.com/pub/UnhidPatt-theInfiniteSoc.pdf
http://www.kurzweilai.net/we-are-now-one-year-away-from-global-riots-complex-systems-theorists-say/comment-page-1#comment-32349
by Jessie Henshaw
The sad thing is that this and other communities aren’t reading the signals, of both how this is a natural complex systems phenomenon of growth beyond comfortable limits, and has one and only one systemic solution.
One of my better overviews of the problem starts with the “signal” that world business suddenly decided to hire mobs of “sustainability advisers”. It was to help them respond to the growing evidence of looming financial liabilities for creating growth ecological and resource conflicts.
http://www.synapse9.com/pub/ASustInvestMoment-PH.pdf
My first paper on it is a little rough, three decades before, is still “right on the money” that growth creates ever more unmanageable changes and unresponsive efforts to deal with them.
http://www.synapse9.com/pub/UnhidPatt-theInfiniteSoc.pdf
I’ve written extensively, awaiting others to realize that studying how nature resolves these same dilemmas, on my blog and archived in extensive basic research in open systems physics on my site:
http://synapse9.com and http://synapse9.com/signals
What’s needed to change the course of events is a conceptually simple whole system transformation, best characterized by how an endowment fund or a small family business manages their money. In the working procedures of finance it’s a change in the purpose of finance, from focusing inward on itself (on its own self-inflation) to focusing outward on others (on serving human needs). That’s the way to end growth without collapsing the system into fragmented disorder.
The familiar local models of successful financial management would need to be applied globally. That is the models provided by “endowment funds” as well as small businesses that stop growing by using their profits for other things. Endowment funds are designed to serve the true purposes of the investors as individuals, as are the profits of a small business once it has grown to the point it can serve family needs. The wealth is created from using seed money accumulated by an investment strategy of self-inflation. Turning the use of the profits outward, to serve greater purposes and needs, is what both ends growth and heals the environment.
That would become the source of funds needed for re-localization, if it were to be successful, but would need to be spread globally as a shift in consciousness, to actually work. That’s how nature does it, which you can confirm by studying any growth system that survives its own growth period.
Collapsing into fragmented disorder is another kind of “re-localization”, but rather undesirable, of course.
http://www.synapse9.com/signals/2012/07/07/astoundingly-expensive-arts-and-crafts/
http://www.synapse9.com/signals/2012/06/09/what-sustainability-degrowth-tend-to-skip/
http://www.synapse9.com/signals/2012/06/07/the-news-of-the-commons/
by chris
A lot of people commenting here dont seem to understand that there is way more to the complex systems being analyzed than is presented in this article.
Trends in economies across the globe given the interrelation and interdependence of governments, markets, and means to modern production are very real indicators of massive increases in political & market instabilities, everywhere.
There will be changes in the relative proportion of effect that global shocks have on different states and local communities, changes which alter some longstanding differences between various developed and various developing nations
by Gagarin Miljkovich
Two great “super solutions” is “Vertical Farming” and “Mining”, the Asteroid Belt between Mars and Jupiter. It gives us endlees resources.
Plese inform yurself about Vertical Farming here: http://http://www.verticalfarm.com/
Mining the asteroidbelt:http://www.space.com/15948-asteroid-belt-space-rocks-infographic.html
by Richard Sittel
I retired to Honduras in Central America a few years ago. It seems that here the price of maize has already doubled in the last 3 years. However, since then, everybody is clearing land and planting corn. The biggest problem with everything is that even though the corn is worth more, getting it to market to sell cost way more than the corn/maize.
by Bri
Same problem here. My landlord brings fruit from upstate NY when he comes back from weekends at his summer house. It just rots on the trees. He can’t bring it to market. That’s how dysfunctional our economy is. Industrial farming has made food less expensive yes, but what we value and how we produce it is out of whack.
by Bill Katakis
The church insists on unlimited reproduction, so do the countries, more people equal bigger armies and more fools for corporate bosses to shake down for every farthing they can earn. It’s what Jesus wants. Ethanol uses food acreage for automotive fuel, it’s not smart to use land for fuel production. We can’t eat ethanol.
by skeptical stan
C’mon quoting Al jazeera….. my eyes glazed and i immediately dismissed this as the propaganda piece that it is.
Get serious.
by fgbouman
Al Jazeera has some of the best and most objective reporting around. Ignoring it can keep one ignorant or misinformed.
by Ted
The person who noted that the riots were not global is absolutely correct. Interestingly, that is also the region where the greatest percentage of population growth is expected. While food prices will increase everywhere, and oil may become more difficult to get from these regions, I don’t see food riots in developed nations any time soon. The closest were the food riots in Mexico when the price of corn caused tortilla prices to increase.
by Gorden Russell
A paper was digested here in the last month or so about graphene for reverse osmosis. Graphene gives the hope of cheap desalinization. Somebody has to get off the dime and invest in this research so solar-powered plants can be built to pipe in freshwater to dying crops. If we did it here in the U.S. it would be on the scale of building the Interstate system. But once the pipelines are taking freshwater up from the Gulf to the Dakotas, we will save a lot of this country.
by Daniel
Pipeline? Are you kidding me? Across state lines so all the polls can hold it hostage and the freaking eco freaks can freak out about damaged bugs. It might seem reasonable in a different political climate but the one we have now where earth worms outrank humans, good luck with pipe lines.
by DeBee Corley
What’s the big deal? More people = more brains.
Super crises, super solutions.
Or, famine, pestilence, death and destruction.
Fortunately, our children are being raised as prey. The predators will find easy pickings.
by Gorden Russell
Then get a Ruger 10/22 and take your kids to the nearest quarry on Sunday afternoon and set up milk bottles filled with water (and a few drops of red food coloring). Teach them to plink and they won’t end up prey.
by Hugh Glass
I agree with the more people=more brains: but unfortunately, that will be discounted by the ‘whack-a-mole’ social system which exists today.
The best & brightest are discouraged by an education system which discourages individual achievement….an army of bureaucrats who regulate all they do not agree with (or do not understand)…..and a police force whose delusions of grandeur cause them to see Navy Seals when they pass by a mirror.
(And at least in the case of my family,when the predation begins, the “predators” will find out that they are NOT as high up the food chain as they believed they were!)
by fgbouman
That sounds like Chairman Mao’s “with each mouth come two hands”. Nonsense. Or at least a non sequitur.
by Marcos Marin
Remember a recent news item, also featured here on the newsletter, about a group of scientists who were trying to simulate history? I think the headline alluded to us being simulated automatons somewhere :-)
Dear Editor, may I suggest adding that piece to the “Related” section of this one? I’d like to re-read that story, if possible… thank you.
by Editor
done
by Marcos Marin
Thanks!! =)
by snake0
Am I the only one that looks at that graph and sees nothing more than a random walk? The source period is a mere 8 years. Demagoging is the go-to occupation of failed statisticians it would seem.
by Khannea Suntzu
Deny deny deny “this stuff is politically inconvenient, make it go awaaaay*
by Kevin Haskell
I think Europe would go down first if anything happens. Greece is just a forerunner because the problems they face are faced by most of Europe. Once Germany starts sliding, they’ll be no other economic rope to grab onto. They are very vulnerable, right now, and just hanging on by a few strings, strings that are being pulled.
by Mr.X
Maybe you should take a look at your own economy… You guys tend to underestimate Europeans.
by Bri
What country are you writing from. I have two acquaintances that go back to Italy. They say it’s really bad over there. I have a client who just came back from Cypress he says that it’s really bad over there. My buiness associate is from Poland. He says it’s really bad over there’s. The Germans didn’t want to join the union because of issues like these. It may not be great over here but we have a lot of fat to live off so to speak.
by fgbouman
We have far less fat to live off than you seem to think. Three years of back-to-back droughts and we’ll be on our knees.
by Kevin Haskell
Oh no, ours is awful, too. I’m just saying that Europe has already started down the road to riots, giving them a head-start. Even the wealthier European nations could see the same within the year. Personally, I have serious doubts, and this graph clearly shows that different regions of the planet are harmed to different degrees at various times. Wealthier nations should be able to weather any food shortages, but not without some financial hardship, and again, this is always an ‘if’ proposition. The world has dealt with worse drought conditions and come through, one as recently as 1988, according to NOAA.
http://www.c3headlines.com/2012/09/latest-report-from-noaa-confirms-us-drought-is-not-extreme-climate-change.html.
by Kevin Haskell
Regarding Europe’s present state of instability, the Nation magazine recently published this. Even the Hague, for example, is starting to show signs of weakness as a once-pillar of strength.
http://www.thenation.com/article/169756/what-remains-european-union
by Kevin Haskell
With one million people marching in Catalonia for secession from Spain, at twice the levels of support seen in 2008.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/sep/11/barcelona-march-catalan-independence?INTCMP=SRCH
by Kevin Haskell
And lastly, this recent news from Europe:
http://www.businessweek.com/news/2012-08-31/euro-area-unemployment-at-record-11-dot-3-percent-inflation-quickens
by fgbouman
When there are food shortages, people don’t eat and some die. That’s far beyond mere “financial hardship”. Food doesn’t appear magically when the price is high enough – it simply disappears into the kitchens of the wealthy while the poor starve. One cannot be an economist and simply “assume” a bag of wheat.
by snake0
Scientific rigor has nothing to do with politics. In fact when people are discouraged from refuting popular theories because it is a ‘touchy subject’, THEN it indeed becomes more about politics than science. You may note that I didn’t deny anything, I merely pointed out the fallacies of the author’s scientific method. 8 years of data proves absolutely nothing, if anything people like this are hurting the cause for global warming.
by josdorpjossie
I agree the evidence is not very convincing. In 2008 the riots in somalia started at a food price of 160. I think there is more involved than just te food price. And I don’t like the explanation that is given, “if you can’t eat, you fight”. That part is just made up.
Nevertheless, there is some similarity between the graphs. The food price might very well be an indicator.
by Rob Larson
Wow the old global warming specter. This has nothing to do with the declining purchasing power of the dollar, not at all. Ignore the man behind the curtain. Since 2009, the US has tripled the amount of dollars in circulation. Other than moves by some banks to buy other banks, this money was mostly sat on and not used for anything. Which proved to be a boon. Not that banks are lending money out again, inflation is creeping up, with the resultant rise in all prices; including food. Imagine for a moment the riots which will occur if prices merely double due to this inflation. One wonders what will happen when prices triple as prices seek equilibrium with the new amount of currency floating around out there.
by Khannea Suntzu
In the US. Dollars. How does that pertain to me?
by MedicalQuack
This is scary but might be true and perhaps what I have said for the last year might make sense. We have an economy heavily based on intangibles and we have lost balance and need to invest in tangibles in the US again, as factories make products which create jobs.
Why would a company build a factory and hire employees when they can hire a few geeks and set up the algorithms to mine and sell data. They are all doing it, even companies like Sears and in 2010 Walgreens made just short of $800 million, selling data alone.
It’s time to license and tax and data sellers and require a federal page to where all are required to list what kind of data they sell and to who
It’s one of my Attack of the Killer Algorithms posts. I think about this possibility every time I pay an excise tax on a tire I need so I can drive my car to one of those lesser paying jobs out there:) Think of it, as data selling is ingrained in the business world today and again needs to be licensed and quarterly taxed so the appeal to sell data versus building factories and hiring is not so strong. I can’t eat an algorithm for lunch but I sure need the tangibles to eat.
http://ducknetweb.blogspot.com/2012/07/congress-to-investigate-data-sellers.html
We have all become “Algo Duped” in a large way.
http://ducknetweb.blogspot.com/2012/07/big-data-flawed-data-business.html
by Porkov
From a historical perspective, the one thing worse for agriculture than global warming is global cooling. So when, in geological terms, has there NOT been climate change? And more to the point, what technology can we use to stabilize climate and control weather at an optimum level? What IS the optimum level? Who gets to control the setting of the thermostat at your house?
by trakk
There has been, but it has occurred over thousands of years. And now because of our activities it is happening in decades.
by Bruce Wright
Previous historical climate change has most certainly NOT occurred over “thousands of years” – rather, often in decades to centuries at most. The concerns this time are that
(1) To the extent that the current warming trend is man-made, this is quite different from historical climate change drivers, and would tend to make the trend more difficult to reverse.
(2) If some of the climate models come to pass, the magnitude of the current changes may become much greater than many previous historical climate changes.
by Mark Harrison
Let’s look at the countries from 2010-2012
Algeira – North Africa
Saudi Arabi – Middle East
Mauritania – North Africa
Sudan – Central / North Africa
Yemen – Middle East
Oman – Middle East
Morocco – North Africa
Egypt – North Africa
Iraq – Middle East
Bahrain – Middle East
Libya – North Africa
Syria – Middle East
Tunisia – North Africa
Uganda – Central / East Africa
That word ‘Global’… I’m not sure it means what you think it means.
by L2k4FC
Good point. A lot of oil in those countries too. However if India makes it back on the list that goes a long way toward making it “global” not just because they are a nuclear power. And, if things do continue to get worse, the countries you have listed [the weakest ones of all] are where we will see what is to come for all in a worst case scenario.
by Mr.X
Yeah, they are being eurocentric.
by Hoss
In just a few years every square inch of Earth will be measured and monitored, and the resources rationed. When the population is 8 billion and citizens of the US no longer have a bargaining advantage over citizens of say, Zambia, a hundred acre crop failure could devastate the entire food distribution network, as the margins will be increasingly thin. Would be a good time for some serious advances in nanotechnology.
by Singularity Utopia
Plutocratic idiots running our nations in headless-chicken-utterly-clueless-mode, that’s the problem. Damn the oligarchy! Damn the repressive nepotism stiffing new ideas.
by Gastrolith
Oh dear, so much speculative nonsense in one story. And the irony is that corn prices are so high because half the US corn crop now goes to biofuel.
by Editor
Could you expand on your critique?
by Bill
It seems that the percentage used for ethanol is between 16 and 40 percent, depending on what interpretation you accept. Which is not half, but is pretty dang significant, especially since there are non-food crop ways of producing ethanol, never mind the fact that ethanol is an inefficient source of fuel for transportation and in effect is not very green at all considering all the farmland, pesticide, water and energy it takes to produce and transport it.
http://www.growthenergy.org/news-media/press-releases/un-spreading-misinformation-about-biofuels/
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/31/opinion/corn-for-food-not-fuel.html
by Gorden Russell
Fuel will soon come from algae. That’s got to help some.
by Gorden Russell
Shades of Hari Seldon.
by SpottedMarley
woooooooooohoooooooooooo!! *arms up in the air*
this is one hell of a rollercoaster
by Bri
Just close your eyes. Click your heals together three times and say. There’s no global warming, there’s no global warming, there’s no global warming. After that as the good witch Glienda waves her wand say, man’s activities have no impact. After that say George Bush’s line, the fundamentals of our economy are sound. As I listen to today’s politics all I see is the same ignorance. The word comes from ignore. We are smart enough but we purposefully ignore. They scratch their heads and say that all we need are more jobs. We are one trillion in debt for student loans. I’ve spoken to so many people that have masters and doctorate degrees that can’t find jobs. They typically take whatever job they can get. Sometimes even menial ones. Over the next five years the first wave of autonomous robots will come onto the scene. The next five years after we’ll see ones that rival our intelligence. There is this huge tidal wave about to inundate us and it’s like what happened in the pacific. As the waters get sucked out of the bays we take out our cameras. Absolutely clueless! It’s not even showing up on any politians radar. We have nice new toys to quell the riots. Anyone who fights that way will die quickly. If your hoping that this dry spell is an fluke just check out the latest climatic forecasts. This will be a wetter period compared to what’s coming. The worlds bread baskets are drying up. It’s a good time to create farm land in Canada though!
by Mr.X
I do not think that politicans are that ignorant.You just have to take into account that they serve themselves first. Maybe I have an interesting book tip for you: “The Dictator’s Handbook: Why Bad Behavior is Almost Always Good Politics.”
I borrowed it from a friend in my quest to rule.Now I’am the dominant personality in my head!
by Phillfrog
I think this will put pressure on the powers that be to relax GM crop restrictions and probably even cause them to encourage the development of more robust, higher yield GM crops.
by asiwel
Also seems past time to stop subsidizing corn ethanol and using food crops as energy sources.
by Gorden Russell
The world can certainly use those drought-resistant corn plants that are being developed now.
by Khannea Suntzu
The world can certainly use that Expelliarmus spell developed at Hogwarts right this very moment.
by melis256
What the hell is that supposed to mean?
http://www.purdue.edu/newsroom/research/2012/120718TuinstraResearch.html
by Kevin Haskell
Yes. I have some pretty high hopes for these latest genetically altered drought-fighting seeds that require far less water to grow.
Science seems to be dealing with the worst of any droughts by using the lastest in genetically modified seeds.
“Monsanto’s DroughtGard corn is the latest development in molecular crop science. A gene from the bacterium Bacillis subtilis is inserted in the DNA of corn; the resulting plants tolerate drought more effectively and require less water in nondrought conditions. Anything that reduces the devastation of drought and reduces water consumption in “normal” times warrants attention.” – Wall Street Journal
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444327204577617131256432156.html?KEYWORDS=Monsanto+and+the+drought